Friday, June 03, 2005

Genetics and sexual orientation in fruit flies

So neuroscientists have made lesbian flies. Well, sort of. NYTimes story here, actual articles here and here (back-to-back articles in the prestigious journal Cell - you probably need a subscription to access the full text). Quick summary:
[One gene], the researchers are announcing today in the journal Cell, is apparently by itself enough to create patterns of sexual behavior - a kind of master sexual gene that normally exists in two distinct male and female variants.

In a series of experiments, the researchers found that females given the male variant of the gene acted exactly like males in courtship, madly pursuing other females. Males that were artificially given the female version of the gene became more passive and turned their sexual attention to other males.
As always, the NYTimes write-up makes a little bit too much of the study. In particular, it says that "The finding supports scientific evidence accumulating over the past decade that sexual orientation may be innately programmed into the brains of men and women." Um, these studies were done in fruit flies. It hardly seems that it should be necessary to point out that fruit flies have much simpler nervous systems than humans and are much less capable of complex behaviors and learning. I don't want to put up humans on a separate plane from animals - we are animals, still, and human sexual orientation does have an innate component - but it is really stretching the absurd to infer the genetics of sexual orientation in humans from fruit flies. (David Velleman makes a similar point.)

The significance of this study has nothing to do with whether homosexuality is innate in humans or not, but lies rather in the novel demonstration that a single gene switch can control a stereotyped behavior through the development of a neural circuit, in the same way that a single gene switch can control the development of body parts (the analogy is to the fly gene eyeless, which is necessary and sufficient for eye formation).

One of the funny things about the NYTimes article is that it depicts the scientists as shocked and disbelieving, e.g. "The observing scientist looked with disbelief at the show, for the suitor in this case was not a male, but a female that researchers had artificially endowed with a single male-type gene." In fact, this result is pretty well expected, and I imagine that the experimentor was looking on not with disbelief, but rather a sigh of relief that the experiment worked and the hypothesis was confirmed.

The "fruitless" hypothesis of male courtship in the fruit fly was proposed almost 10 years ago. See here (under "Biological Overview") for a nice, if technical, summary of how the gene fruitless was thought to control male courtship behavior. Basically, the gene fruitless can encode several different protein products depending on how the message is processed (alternative mRNA splicing), and males and females produce different protein products. These fruitless protein products are transcription factors that then go on to control the expression of other genes, ultimately leading to differences in neural circuitry and hence behavior. So this latest result is not that surprising in its essence - what's surprising is how clean the result was and how completely fruitless controls courtship behavior.

Even so, the results weren't quite as clean as the NYTimes made them out to be. Females expressing the male variant of fruitless carried out most of the male courtship ritual, but spent less time licking tthe court-ee than wild-type males did. They also spent less time courting than wild-type males did during the 8 minute assay (40% v. 90% - though this difference could be due to the fact that the assay ended when males succeeded in copulating, which was obviously impossible for the mutant females). But this is just details - overall, the result is really remarkably clean.

One final point: one interesting facet of the second study is that males and females don't have many obvious anatomical differences in the neural circuitry that is controlled by fruitless. I'll quote the article:
We do not think it is their gross anatomy. With the trivial exception of neurons innervating the reproductive organs, we detect only subtle differences in the numbers of these neurons and no differences at all in their morphologies or projections. Pending further studies at higher resolution, we tentatively conclude that sex differences in courtship behavior do not rest on differences in the production, survival, or connectivity of the neurons involved.

This conclusion offers a rather sobering perspective on the considerable effort that continues to be devoted to identifying and characterizing sexual dimorphisms in the mammalian brain. In Drosophila, the sexual behaviors of males and females are dramatically different and highly stereotyped; we can attribute this difference to a single splicing event in a single gene, and we can examine the neurons that express this gene at single-cell resolution. Yet even under these ideal circumstances, we still cannot find any anatomical differences that might account for the dramatically different sexual behaviors of males and females. This suggests that differences in neural chemistry, rather than gross neuroanatomy, might underlie the profound differences in behavior between males and females in Drosophila, and surely in many other species as well.
In a way, I'd have been disappointed if it was the gross neuroanatomy instead of subtle molecular and cellular differences. The fantastic complexity of the brain at every level of analysis from anatomy to molecules - even in the simple fly - is maddening at times, but it's what makes neuroscience such an interesting field to be in at the moment.

8 Comments:

Anonymous drugs without prescription said...

Mens health drugs

Viagra generic drug is taken by mouth as needed between four hours and one-half hour before sexual activity (about one hour before is most effective). Take only as directed, usually once daily as needed. Sildenafil works along with sexual stimulation to help achieve an erection. Order discount generic or brand Viagra pharmacy online.

Generic CIALIS drug was shown to improve, up to 36 hours after dosing, the ability of men with ED to have a single successful intercourse attempt. CIALIS has not been studied for multiple sexual attempts per dose. Order discount generic or brand Cialis pharmacy online

Generic Levitra drug is taken orally when needed between 4.30 hrs and 30 minutes before sexual activity. Take Levitra only as directed, usually once daily as needed. Levitra works along with sexual stimulation to help achieve an erection. Order discount generic or brand Levitra pharmacy online

Generic Soma drug relaxes muscles and relieves pain and discomfort associated with strains, sprains, spasms or other muscle injuries. Muscle relaxers are for specific muscle injury and pain and should not be used for general body aches and pains. Order discount generic Soma Carisoprodol pharmacy online

Generic Acyclovir drug is used to treat herpes infections of the skin, mouth, mucous membranes, genital herpes, herpes zoster (shingles), and chickenpox in some individuals. This medication does not cure herpes, but relieves the pain and may make the infection clear faster. Order discount generic Acyclovir pharmacy online

Generic Famvir drug (Famciclovir) is used to treat herpes zoster (shingles) and genital herpes. It does not cure herpes infections but decreases pain and itching, helps sores to heal, and prevents new ones from forming. Order discount generic or brand Famvir Famciclovir pharmacy online

Generic Valtrex drug (Valacyclovir) is an antiviral agent used in the treatment of shingles (herpes zoster) or genital herpes. Order discount brand or generic Valtrex Valacyclovir pharmacy online

5/01/2008 02:59:00 PM  
Blogger dr said...

Cialis and Viagra are a simple and efficacious way to solve erectile dysfunction, a problem that almost all of us face. According to the studies, Cialis has proved effective in 80% of the men who suffered from erectile dysfunction, so there are high chances Cialis will also work for you. http://www.buy-cialis-online-now.com

3/31/2009 05:33:00 AM  
Blogger Dr.tom said...

As soon as you administer Viagra to the system, its chief chemical component sildenafil citrate springs into action and starts inhibiting the PDE 5 enzyme. Alongside the inhibition of PDE 5 enzyme, the administration of viagra also accelerates the effect of nitric oxide and it leads to the smooth flow of blood to the penis and as a consequence, the person becomes capable of facilitating erections necessary for sexual intercourse.

4/09/2009 11:24:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This years is poker cards and no needed deposit free poker sponsorship from poker portal. Free money capital for new poker donkey.
Give All possible no deposit cash bonus poker pages & cake free poker cash bankroll.
More green free 25 dollar signup bonuses online card poker are bet and just holdem, give's all new players.Titan poker needed free start capital $50 bonuses for online poker.
First site no deposit online poker bonuses is that free no deposit promotion glory be worry all time.
poker cash without deposit $220 Titan token gold $250 guaranteed prize fund for you and low gamblers.
We have great oportunity free money for start play and this is not to me free chips at party tables or texas rooms. That mean that cd poker platform is most in progress.
More country like Israel Moldowa and Belarus want free instant buy cheap poker bankrolls and that is no suspect that blog.
Enjoy free poker profesionall free start capital bonus for poker with password to made hudge victory.
Mike have No deposit POKER signup bonuses only for fifty person, Free poker money no quiz is soft decide to capitale italy.
Texas rule and free bonus no quiz be fine and daily freeroll with buyin 2$ for more cash no deposit bonus rackback.
Scarry poker movie deposit first poker blog try it will be $50 bankrolls, great omaha news.

7/11/2009 02:56:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Promo poker texas hold'em Full tilt $50 dolarów za darmo Party poker i Titan - online.

7/11/2009 02:58:00 PM  
Anonymous inversiones financieras said...

hello fellas, I just want to emphasize the good work on this blog, has excellent views and a clear vision of what you are looking for.

3/01/2010 07:04:00 AM  
Blogger FeNaaa said...

The latter, Web 2.0, is not defined as a static architecture. Web 2.0 can be generally characterized as a common set of architecture and design patterns, which can be implemented in multiple contexts. bu sitede en saglam pornolar izlenir.The list of common patterns includes the Mashup, Collaboration-Participation, Software as a Service (SaaS), Semantic Tagging (folksonomy), and Rich User Experience (also known as Rich Internet Application) patterns among others. These are augmented with themes for software architects such as trusting your users and harnessing collective intelligence. Most Web 2.0 architecture patterns rely on Service Oriented Architecture in order to function

11/03/2010 01:32:00 PM  
Anonymous Invertir en oro said...

I think it's important that we all know a little about this subject so interesting, I think it's part of human culture tell us about such things.
Invertir en petroleo

4/14/2011 04:58:00 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home